Reviews
Michael
Carpenter
SOOP #1
"Just after the April, 2001 update went up, I received Mr. Carpenter's
CD of cover songs by some of his favorite artists.
This type of CD is usually something that I am uninterested in; however,
in Carpenter's case, the work is more
than interesting. It is a blueprint of how a great songwriter becomes
one. An artist is the sum of those artists that
he or she admires. Carpenter lays that equation out for us here, and
the total is impressive indeed.
The opening track, "King's Highway", a Tom Petty cover, is a tour de
force. The rising, anthemic guitars, the
tambourine on the choruses, the in-time cascading drums, and outstanding
arrangement brought me back to
the time that I first heard "American Girl." Petty has had a real career
for a reason. He really is one of the great
rock songwriters of our era. Carpenter recognizes this, and this song
is a great tribute to Mr. Petty.
He'd love this version. The second track, an obscure Beatles cover,
underscores Carpenter's true
understanding of what made the Beatles great. They played 1-4-5 rock-n-roll
for years before they redefined the genre.
They cut their teeth in the clubs, and were a great live band (when
you could hear them over the screams).
Like The Beatles, Carpenter plays a gig almost every night in his native
Australia. There may not be a harder
working musician anywhere. Playing makes you better. It worked for The
Beatles; it works for Carpenter.
He covers "This Will Be Our Year" by The Zombies. Jazz-pop pioneers
and fathers of the prog rock movement,
The Zombies wrote some of the greatest songs in an era dominated by
The Beatles. Purists call them a better band.
That Carpenter tries this shows his good taste. He tackles "Rain". I
cringed at first, because a cover of
this song is a tall order. But he nails it, and it even has that "Rain" vibe. Great job.
He tackles Sam Cooke, maybe the greatest singer of all time.
But where this recording really shines is the versions of The Beach
Boys' "Wild Honey" and "You're So Good To Me". Carpenter is a '70s Brother-era
Beach Boys disciple, and these versions really shine.
Available in a limited edition of 500, this release is worthy of purchase
for its collectible nature at the least.
At the most, it is a journey into the pieces of the puzzle that make
a great artist become who he or she is.
This unique recording can be purchased directly from the artist at www.mcarp.com,
and in the United States
through Not Lame Recordings (www.notlame.com), his Stateside label.
You can e-mail him directly at stagefright@msn.com.au "
Review by Fufkin.com (website)
MICHAEL CARPENTER
SOOP#1
"Michael Carpenter’s third release as a solo artist is a covers album
(SOOP = Songs of other people).
It is a credit to Michael as both a producer and a performer that he has
managed to present songs by a group
of artistes as disparate as Arthur Alexander, The Beatles, Sam Cooke, Bob
Dylan and Bruce Springsteen,
and manage to do so in such a tight and cohesive manner, without diluting
the spirit of the songs he has recorded.
Although the final track listing was decided by votes from fans via his
website, the song selection is clearly
a reflection of Michael’s influences. His recordings of songs by The Beatles,
The Beach Boys, Bob Dylan
(via The Byrds), The Monkees and The Zombies point to Carpenter’s passion
for glorious 60s pop.
The collection is bookended by two Tom Petty songs, which works well, Petty
being one of the most talented
and successful protégés of these same influences. Ultimately, this album
proves to be an
invigorating and entertaining salute to those who made Michael Carpenter
what he is today
(musically speaking, that is). A delightful diversion. SOOP #1 can be ordered
through Not Lame,
or from Michael directly via his website: www.mcarp.com But hurry as numbers
are limited. "
Review
by Jimm @ Go Pop! (Fanzine)
MICHAEL
CARPENTER
SOOP
#1
( Big Radio/www.mcarp.com
)
"The
resounding success of the Beatles made it virtually mandatory for recording
artists to sing their own songs.
Certainly, before the 1960s, the roles of composer and performer were largely
separate ones. Of course, the
mainstream pop scene has returned to that scenario with current pop stars
hardly figuring in the songwriting
arena. Whilst the constant barrage of today's pop stars singing well-known
cover tunes has left a bad taste in
serious rock and pop enthusiasts' mouths, there has emerged another recent
rising trend. This has allowed
artists to record familiar material but presented as a tribute to the composer
in question or to highlight an inventive
approach that is consistent with the said musician's own sound and vision.
In the latter category, the likes of Mark Kozelek, with his acoustic, stripped
down interpretation of AC/DC songs
(What's Next to the Moon) and Jon Auer, with his idiosyncratic treatment
of diverse source material (6½) have
already set a healthy precedent for this nascent movement. Add to the list,
Aussie popster Michael Carpenter,
who comes with an array of tunes that reflect his own personal tastes and
preferences.
Titled SOOP i.e. "songs of other people," this collection of power pop tracks
will not surprise anyone familiar
with Carpenter's own material, which can be found on his excellent albums,
Baby and Hopefulness (available from
Not Lame Records). No surprise then that the selections range from breezy
folk-rock Tom Petty’s “King’s Highway,”
The Byrds version of Dylan’s “Chimes of Freedom” to Beatles-Beach Boys arch
pop “Rain,” “I’ll Get You,” “Wild Honey”
and “You So Good to Me.” Not to mention the surprise hidden 13th track.
*Sigh*
Less obvious perhaps is Carpenter’s decision to render Zombies’ “This Will
Be Our Year,” Springsteen’s
“I Wish I Were Blind” and Sam Cooke’s “Wonderful World” in a style that
makes no compromise or deviation from
Carpenter’s recognisable pop “formula.” Which speaks volumes for Carpenter’s
pedigree and degree of confidence
in his own ability. Released in a limited run of 500 copies, I suggest you
secure a copy of SOOP #1 post-haste,
you will not regret it! (8) "
Review by POWER OF POP Website 1/6/01
Michael
Carpenter
SOOP
#1
(Big Radio Records)
"A
couple of weeks ago, when writing about The Band's Moondog Matinee, I asked,
semi-rhetorically, if
covers
LPs ever worked. With SOOP #1, Carpenter proves that they can work and work
extremely well.
He pulls it off by coming at it from a different angle. Instead of using
it as a tool to clear writer's block, revitalize a
stale band, or indulge in a little public dues paying, he tackles a dozen
songs just 'cause he likes them.
Recorded over the course of six years, many tracks were laid down quickly
in spare studio moments, and despite being
one or two man affairs (and by definition, heavily overdubbed) they crackle
with a freshness and vitality that's rare
even for a band recorded live off the floor - doubly so built it pieces.
The opening "King's Highway" betters Tom Petty's original by upping the
jangle factor and emphasizing the pure pop
aspects of the song. The Beach Boy's "Wild Honey" is even better; Carpenter
really let 'er rip on the vocal, recalling the
grit and passion of John Lennon's early Beatle work. A dose of gutsy guitar
also gives it some extra oomph. It's odd
that a pure pop master like Carpenter can bring something fresh to a Beach
Boys song by adding some Beatley elements
and then follow it immediately with a Beatles cover that doesn't work nearly
as well. "Rain" - not bad by any
yardstick - hews too closely to the original. He states in his liner notes
that it was his intention to recreate the original,
so it gets rated an unqualified success on that front (sounds like he a
ball trying, too), but it doesn't meet the exceptional
level of the rest of the LP. The glockenspiel he adds to Sam Cooke's "Wonderful
World" lends some
Buddy Holly charm, while the discreet steel guitar brings in a subtly Byrdsy
atmosphere. There's considerably
more Byrds to be found in "Chimes of Freedom," where he combines their version
with Dylan's and Springsteen's -
the organ and bass, in particular, recall the Boss' take. And then he tackles
Bruce by covering one of the more
overlooked songs from his catalog. "I Wish I Were Blind," from Human Touch,
is gentle and sorrowful.
And in a final Beach Boys homage, there's a hidden track. "Our Prayer," originally intended for the BB's Smile LP,
is a minute or so of heavenly a cappella massed harmony gauze. The LP is
available from Michael's web site and is
a hand numbered (and autographed) limited edition of 500. Now, where's SOOP
#2? "
Record of the Week (27/5/01)
Review
by John F. Butland (TOAST MAGAZINE)